How to Make Yoghurt From Scratch in an “Easiyo Yogurt Maker”

Making Yogurt from scratch in an Easiyo |

Making yoghurt from scratch is actually far easier than most people realise. The trickiest part is figuring out how to keep your yoghurt at an even temperature (of around 40 degrees Celsius) while it is forming.

And that’s where the Easiyo comes into it’s own.

Now, the Easiyo Yogurt Maker is sold with the assumption that you will buy the Easiyo sachets to make your yoghurt with, not make it from scratch, but there is absolutely no reason you need to do it that way.

What I tend to do is to keep a couple of their flavoured sachets in the cupboard for special treats (for flavours that I haven’t figured out how to make myself), or for when I run out of yoghurt for my starter or have no milk (or milk powder) to spare.

The rest of the time I make my yoghurt from scratch, using one of the following methods. My kids go through a lot of yoghurt, so making it from scratch saves me a lot of money, plus I like being in control of exactly what goes into it. (Note: I’ve now added a Making Yoghurt at Home FAQ & Troubleshooting guide.)

Making yoghurt from scratch using fresh milk

  1. Heat 1 litre of milk almost (but not quite) to boiling – look for the point when it is just slightly frothy on top but not yet foaming up (or use a milk thermometer if you have one). Organic milk is of course best, but not essential, and you can use anything from fat free milk to full cream (4%) milk. Heating the milk changes the protein to make it more conducive to making yoghurt with. It also kills off any bacteria that is growing in the milk and might compete with the yoghurt starter culture.
  2. Easiyo Yogurt MakerCool the milk in the fridge until it is completely cold. Note, this is different to other methods of making yoghurt from scratch.* I tend to heat the milk before bed and leave it in the fridge overnight.
  3. When the milk is completely cold, pour half of it into an Easiyo 1 litre container and add 1/2 cup of milk powder. This is not essential, but makes for a thicker yoghurt. Put the lid on tightly. Shake until mixed, the same way you would using an Easiyo sachet.
  4. Take about half a cup of the milk and mix it with 2-3 tbsp of yoghurt, until they are well blended. Make sure the yoghurt is not too old, as your starter bacteria may have died. Tip: If you don’t have any yoghurt left, you can use 2-3 tablespoons of any Easiyo packet as your yoghurt starter. I keep a packet in the cupboard for this purpose, and just keep it in a glass jar once it’s open. If you use a flavoured packet you will get a very mild flavour through your yoghurt.
  5. Add this mix and the rest of the milk to the yoghurt container and shake some more to mix thoroughly.
  6. Fill the Easiyo with boiling water, up to the top of the red baffle, just as for the usual Easiyo instructions.
  7. Put the container of milk into the Easiyo and leave for about 10 hours, depending how tangy and how well set you like your yoghurt (the longer you leave it the tangier and better set it gets). Then take it out and put it in the fridge to finish setting, for 6 hours (this will stop the culturing process).


Variation 1: Making yoghurt from scratch using powdered milk

The Yogurt Cookbook by Arto der Haroutunian

The Yogurt Cookbook includes your basic “how to make yogurt” recipes at the front, but then also covers how to make yogurt cheese, how to make curd cheeses just with lemon juice and milk, including the Indian cream cheese, panir, and then has perhaps a hundred recipes that use yoghurt, from soup to main dishes to desserts.

This is basically the same as above, except without steps 1 & 2, and instead of 1/2 cup of milk powder, I use 1&1/3 to 1&1/2 cups of milk powder, 1 litre of cold water from the tap.

This is much quicker and also doesn’t involve me having to buy yet another litre of milk every two days (my family goes through a LOT of milk already!), but I can understand that food purists might prefer to use fresh milk.

Variation 2: Making yoghurt from scratch using UHT milk

In response to questions in the comments, I have now tried making yoghurt using UHT milk, and I have to confess, this is now my favourite option. It is exactly the same as option 1, without the heating and cooling of the milk, and works perfectly.

You can easily keep a litre or two of UHT milk in the cupboard, without having to clutter up your fridge. It’s probably not as economical as using powdered milk, but still far cheaper than buying ready made yoghurt or Easiyo sachets. And you can buy organic UHT milk at Aldi in Australia (usually). I know you can get organic powered milk, but I haven’t sourced any yet.

Flavouring your Yoghurt

There are different ways of flavouring your yoghurt, which can be done either before setting or afterwards, when serving. One common method is to stir in some jam or some fresh fruit when serving. Unfortunately, half of my family won’t eat yoghurt this way, having gotten too use to the store bought extra sweet stuff. So for them, I sweeten before setting. The two preferred flavours I’ve made this way are lemon (which I love) and vanilla.

For either one of these you just added 2 tablespoons of sugar or honey  and 1 teaspoon of vanilla or lemon essence. When I make the yoghurt with milk I stir in the sugar or honey when the milk is hot so as to dissolve it effectively. If I’m using water and milk powder I just heat up a couple of table spoons of water and dissolve the sugar in that, before mixing in the milk powder and yoghurt. The essence can be added at the same time.

Yogurt: More Than 70 Delicious and Healthy Recipes: Sarina Jacobson, Photography by Danya Weiner

Sarina Jacobson’s book has received 5 stars on Amazon (but the image link is to Fishpond). I haven’t tried it yet, but I’m waiting on some yoghurt books from my library for more recipe ideas.

Experiment with the amount of sweetener you like to use. Two tablespoons is much less sweet than store bought yoghurt usually is, but still sweeter than some people like. Honey gives a quite different flavour compared to sugar. Do not use Xylitol, which seems to inhibit the bacteria from growing. I believe Stevia is the same. You can use them afterwards if you like.

You can also use a few tablespoons of one of the Easiyo sachets as your starter culture, to create a very mild flavour, or more for a stronger, sweeter flavour.

When adding berries or other fruit it is better to add it when serving, as the fruit will just sink to the bottom of the milk before the yoghurt sets (and could curdle your milk, depending on the fruit).

More questions? See my Yogurt FAQ and Troubleshooting page.

*Updated to add: The reason for cooling the milk all the way to cold is to ensure the heat from the boiling water is not enough to kill off the starter culture. However, my mother has reported only cooling to 40°C (which is the usual practice for making yogurt at home) with no issues.

Updated (again) to add: I’ve changed the instructions for making the powdered milk version from one and a quarter, to one and a third or a half cups of milk powder, because – in response to a comment below – I’ve started using more milk powder and found I prefer the consistency. I’ve also changed the instructions from 1-2 tbsp, to 2-3 tbsp of starter, because this seems to give a more consistent result, presumably because of the life cycle of the starter bacteria – if the yoghurt is a bit old, there won’t be as much left. On the other hand, two much culture doesn’t work – there’s too much competition for the “food” (milk sugars), so that it’s all gone before the yoghurt sets. So don’t overdo it.

Free Printables: Non-toxic cleaning in your laundry, kitchen & bathroomYou’ve made your own Yoghurt, would you like to get the stains out of your kids clothes with an easy DIY no-nasties spray?

If you’d like my standard set of non-toxic cleaning recipes for your laundry, kitchen & bathroom, including two pre-wash stain remover sprays for the laundry, consider signing up to get my Free Non-toxic Cleaning Printables.

I have them on my laundry wall, but I know other readers who have them up in their pantry cupboard or even the kitchen wall. When you sign up, I’ll send you the printables, plus the occasional special subscriber only emails.  What’s not to love?

  217 comments for “How to Make Yoghurt From Scratch in an “Easiyo Yogurt Maker”

  1. Junny
    April 19, 2016 at 6:30 am

    I’ve been using the uht method for long and it always work wonder,sometimes when I get enough of yogurt I just need to freeze the starters from my previous batches ,then start all over again …oh I just tried using my 3 month old frozen yogurt from my previous batches and It turn out well also 🙂
    So thanks for sharing this lovely information

  2. Liz
    April 25, 2016 at 1:47 pm

    Hi there, just wondering if anyone has been making yoghurt without the sachets in the 500mL mini maker? I’ve tried just halving the 1L recipe for powdered milk (i.e. 2/3 – 3/4C of milk powder and about 2 spoons of yoghurt) but am yet to get a good result, and don’t want to waste much more yoghurt trying! I always let it set for at least 12 hours if not 14-15, right temp water etc. Any help much appreciated!

  3. Matthew
    May 8, 2016 at 5:49 am

    Could you use fresh lemon juice to flavour the yogurt before setting?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge