Weighing the Advantages and Disadvantages of Solar Power

(This article updated March 2012)

There are not too many people who really want to go back to with living without our modern appliances like stoves, fridges or air conditioners. The problem is that we need to figure out a way for powering our homes without destroying our world around us. Many are considering solar energy as a strong alternative to fossil fuel power. Before we get too excited, let’s consider the advantages and disadvantages of solar power in its various forms.

Environmental Concerns and Storage  – Is Solar as Safe as We Think?

Production

Obviously when using this particular form of renewable energy, one big advantage is low environmental contamination. Unfortunately, many toxic metals and chemicals, lead and cadmium, are used during equipment production. As long as manufactures take appropriate precautions while using and disposing dangerous chemicals this is not too serious an issue, but it must be stated that the making of photovoltaic solar panels is not an entirely clean process.

Solar thermal energy is a different story. While costs are higher, the production of solar thermal systems is considerably cleaner, and the “environmental payback time” is less. Solar thermal energy is used to heat air or water – either to directly heat homes, hot water and swimming pools, or to then generate electricity. It is a different system to the common PV solar panels, and so far less common for electricity generation, though certainly solar hot water systems are very popular in sunny countries like Australia.

Storage

Make Solar & Geothermal Energy Work For You, Harness the sun and earth to power your lifestyle. by Simon MarlowBattery storage can be more of a problem. When using basic golf cart batteries for storage, consumers need to be  cautious of the toxic gasses they can vent. There are batteries that do not vent gasses but they are expensive, running thirty percent more cost-wise.

Of course, many people with grid-connected home solar power systems don’t need battery backup, but storage is still an issue on a larger scale, since solar energy is often not available at peak need times, ie 4-8pm and on especially hot or cold days. However, there are teams of scientists around the world working on this problem, and Maria Forsyth, of the Electromaterials and Corrosion Sciences at Deakin University estimated in March 2012 that safe sodium batteries would be available for small scale devices within five years, and for upscale installations within ten.

Even though these problems with manufacturing are a definite issue, the overall ecological impact of solar power has a far more positive impact than the use of oil as well as gas. Overall, it is estimated that the embodied energy in solar panels will be “paid back” by the energy they produce in two-five years.

Availability

One decided disadvantage of solar power is that it is only available when the sun is shining. That doesn’t just mean your solar panels may generate less electricity on very cloudy days, it means they won’t generate any at all once the sun goes down. Of course, as I pointed out above, that need not be an issue for you if you are grid connected. But on a community wide scale it is very much an issue with solar energy.

Of course, this doesn’t mean solar won’t be a very significant part of the solution to our power needs as we move away from fossil fuels globally, but it does mean it won’t be the sole solution. It will need to be combined not only with storage, but with other methods of energy generation to provide a sustainable and reliable electricity supply.

The Cost of Installing Solar Power

Solar Panels reflect the sunlight

Solar Panels by “Living Off Grid”

Initial costs for harvesting sun light can be overwhelming for the average householder, although the cost of solar panels reduced by almost half in 2011. Basic equipment and installation can still be expensive though. Although DIY solar panels are an option for some, most will need to hire a professional.

However, initial expenses can be recovered over time, eventually providing major savings for a consumer. In areas that have grid connect programs, extra energy generated can often be sold to the power company. There are also federal and state grants and subsidies for installing solar power in many areas, though certainly these come and go. Over all, if up front costs can be managed, a solar power system for your home will likely pay for itself many times over.

Space and Roof Aspect

Solar panels plus the batteries for energy storage (if you use them), take up a lot of space. To have an effective solar power system you will need sufficient roof space with the right orientation. However, your roof does not have to have perfect orientation to be effective (See ‘Is my home suitable for rooftop solar power installation?‘ in our article Installing Residential Solar Power Systems). Technology is advancing; engineers are learning how to shrink panels enough so their size will not be a future concern, as well as making them more effcient, so that orientation is already less critical than it was a couple of decades ago.

So what about sunny vs cloudy days, and what about shade? The fact is that your solar panels will often be more efficient on a partially cloudy day in summer – when it gets too hot, they actually become less efficient. So cloudy days aren’t a particular disadvantage, but shade can be. If your roof is permanently shaded, it’s possible that solar panels will not be the way to go, but do speak to a professional (who can assess your particular situation) before making a call on that.

It has to be said then, that the advantages and disadvantages of solar power generally weigh in on the positive side. The ability to be free from dependency on oil and coal provides a cleaner future with many possibilities. Smaller equipment design, more efficient batteries, and lower cost, are all progressing already. Weighing up the pros and cons of solar energy, the answer is clear: Look up; our future is truly in the sky, shinning above us.

Terry Contento is a freelance writer living and working in Sunny Queensland. His house is powered by solar panels with back up from the grid.

  5 comments for “Weighing the Advantages and Disadvantages of Solar Power

  1. May 31, 2011 at 1:19 pm

    I’ve lived with stand alone solar power for almost 30 years now. We have fridge, washing machine, TV, computer – but we just learn how to choose efficient varieties of all of them, and use them not stintingly but non-wastefully. I think that the major advantage of solar power is a really nice incentive to learn about electricity, what uses ridiculous amounts for the benefit, what is really worth it. It’s hugely empowering to be able to make those choices. It is really nice to be able to consider the whole debate about a carbon tax from a fear-free position.

    • Kirsten
      June 1, 2011 at 12:12 pm

      That’s a really good point Linda. We have been working to get our kids to understand about how different items use electricity, but I’m sure if we went off grid it would quickly make a big difference (to them and us!). In a couple more weeks we will have enough solar power to cover all our needs, and in summer (at least) will be feeding back into the grid. I wonder if we could work out some system where the kids get to choose how to spend a percentage of the profits if we can go above the certain level fed back to the grid?

      By the way, I’m a huge fan of yours – I absolutely *love* The Permaculture Home Garden, and have introduced it to lots of people 🙂

    • mike lot
      August 29, 2011 at 5:17 pm

      Dear Linda, I am considering using solar in my home in Africa and one of the challenges I have had is people saying solar cannot power the kind of equipments you have mentioned. Please advise me on the best ways to use solar to power them and how much of solar power is required. What is the wattage of each of these equipments? Also, are there air conditioners available that can be powerd by solar? I will be grateful for your reply

      • Kirsten
        September 16, 2011 at 1:18 pm

        Hi Mike,

        This isn’t Linda’s website actually, she just left a comment. Your best bet is probably to get advice from a solar installer where you are, I’m afraid I can’t advise you on that level of detail. I can say though, that it is certainly possible to power an entire house with solar power.

        Cheers
        Kirsten

  2. July 2, 2015 at 3:19 am

    I have a house which is powered by solar energy, and I can say that yes, it can power an entire house. We got washing machine, TV, personal computers and other gadgets at home. And it is all powered by solar. It’s a great choice to turn into this green technology.
    DBM Solar recently posted..Rapid Shutdown Switch NEC 609.12 2014My Profile

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge